Score: 9

"So, less IS more."

submission: Pencilmation 11

date: December 11, 2009

Your animation is traditional in many ways. I'm never a fan of the squiggly lines but either you have style or didn't feel like animating the 3 frame re-draw of the static poses for char and background. No matter what the means, the ends came out better than what I usually expect from the squiggle style. Keep it up, I like your ability to tell a story.

Score: 10

"Better and Better"

submission: the YuYu

date: May 3, 2006

I've always idolized your work and your particle and smoke animation was godly in this submission. I'll be waiting for your next animation.

Score: 0

"This isn't for the portal"

submission: Baystream Anim. Interview

date: May 2, 2006

Who is you?

This isn't even flash, we call this the flash portal for reasons beyond the file extension being .swf. FYI: I don't think anyone wants to hear the background of an unheard of animator, if you'd really call yourself one.

Score: 0

"I gave you 5 - 5"

submission: Ducken Sie Erzählungen

date: May 24, 2005

Clocks are zeroish

Score: 10

"Welcome back"

submission: The Non-Livingstons #001

date: April 27, 2005

I could tell that you were the author of the steven segal show in the first five seconds of the animation. I grew up into flash by you, probably all the way back in the 90's if I can remember correctly. I loved the movie, just professional entertainment, I'm looking forward to the next episode.

Score: 9

"I'm confused"

submission: Element trailer

date: April 2, 2005

I have paranoid thoughts about people tracing over actual professional anime clips, so this flash is kind of suspicious. But aside from my suspicion/jealousy, I think its great. You should make it clear to others that this isn't a preview, its a one-time collage of animation you did. You could start by taking the word trailer out. that's my two cents, if it means anything to you.

Score: 10

"What can I say"

submission: The Real Legend 2

date: April 2, 2005

If I see another zelda tribute, parody or spoof, im gonna vomit on my screen. But I'm not going to judge your movie based on the theme. I love the graphics and the animation, priceless work on it. Don't take offense to the 0 on humor, somehow I never get a luagh out of flash movies, I wish I did though. I wouldn't cheer on a part 3, because of my hating zelda tributes thing, but I do want to see more work from you. I voted 4, good job.

Score: 8

"Nice work"

submission: -Downfall-

date: March 25, 2005

This is just quality flash here. The thought was nice and your graphics were unique. A few more flash movies and your animation won't be as awkward as that plane. It comes with practice. still a great piece of work though.

Score: 4

"Sorry"

submission: Television

date: February 12, 2005

I've seen one to many Salad Fingers wanna-be movies. You basically rip off the Scribbler. I have to give you a 1 for your unoriginality. 9 for graphics because you mimic-ed the style very well. But 0 for style because it isn't your style.

Score: 8

"Like it"

submission: Scribbler

date: January 26, 2005

awww poor ericgrabuski, he's all upset because he doesn't like the way Firth made fun of people who is just like him. I'm sure the scribbler was just a hired actor, don't get your panties in a bunch eric. Love the flash, but his ecstatic or pill taking moments kinda spoiled the movie. But still, it was really good.